Shreya Jaiswal
Food history · Data · Part 1

Ancient Rome’s Spice Obsession vs. Italy’s Lack Thereof

I used 1,500 ancient, medieval and modern recipes to investigate Roman cooking and compare it with its modern Italian counterpart.

"India, the Seres, and the Arabian Peninsula, withdraw from our empire one hundred millions of sesterces every year … so dearly do we pay for our luxury and our women."

Pliny the Elder, Natural History, 77 CE

It’s the first century CE, and Imperial Rome is overflowing with spices. Ships return from India with black and long pepper, ginger and malabathrum. Saffron arrives from Asia Minor, and silphium from North Africa. Pliny the Elder laments that not a year goes by without India draining at least 50 million sesterces from the empire, on goods that sold for a hundred times their original cost.

Fig. 01 · Rome’s spice routesApicius
Imported from outside the empire Grown inside the empire By sea Overland or by river

Circles are sized by the number of recipes. Routes are simplified to show direction and ports, not exact sailing lanes. Hover a circle for details.

With that much money pouring into foreign aromatics, one might reasonably assume Roman dishes were flush with spice, hardly what comes to mind when we think of Italian cooking today. What did Romans actually eat, and is it the ancestor of the Italian food we know?

An ancient text offers some clues, and they upend that picture: Rome’s spice obsession barely reached its kitchen, and almost nothing that did made it to the modern Italian table.

A foolish gourmand gives us a glimpse into the Roman table

Marcus Gavius Apicius was a rich first-century gourmand, known for philosophizing about and experimenting with food, but mocked for his excess by Pliny and Seneca. His death, as Seneca tells it, was a fitting end for Rome’s most famous glutton:

"After he had spent a hundred millions of sesterces on his kitchen … he calculated that he would have ten millions left of his fortune, and, as though he would live a life of mere starvation on ten millions, put an end to his life by poison."

Seneca, To Helvia, on Consolation 10

Apicius is the only substantial collection of Roman recipes to survive, and its naming was probably a nod to what he stood for rather than a credit for the recipes. Apicius likely doesn’t have an author in any real sense, argues Sally Grainger, a food historian. Its Latin is plain kitchen language, full of inconsistent spellings, repeated recipes and changing words for the same task. Unlike elite writers such as Cato or Columella, it never introduces itself or explains its purpose. It reads like the work of many cooks, likely enslaved, over a long time, compiled into the form we have around 400 CE.

Since it was written by cooks but named for a famous glutton, it’s unclear whether it reflects everyday or elite eating. Nonetheless, it’s still the best glimpse of a Roman kitchen we will get. I counted every ingredient in its 458 numbered recipes.

They bought the entire spice route, then only cooked with pepper

Rome spent fortunes on the East, but apart from pepper, it barely cooked with what it bought. Black pepper is in 74% of the recipes, the most common ingredient in the book. The second most common is laser, an import from Persia that stood in for the lost silphium.

"It is quite surprising that the use of pepper has come so much into fashion … its only desirable quality being a certain pungency; and yet it is for this that we import it all the way from India!"

Pliny the Elder, Natural History 12.14
Fig. 02 · Every ingredient in Apicius458 recipes

They used weird aromatics, but just homegrown

After pepper, the most-used seasonings are lovage, cumin, rue, coriander and oregano, all grown around the Mediterranean, inside the empire.

Most of those have since dropped out of Italian cooking. Lovage and rue are rare in the kitchens of Rome’s former lands today. Cumin and coriander thrive in Indian, Middle Eastern and Thai cooking, but by 1891 Artusi uses cumin in just one recipe and coriander in five. Silphium, the original source of laser, is gone altogether. It grew around Cyrene in North Africa, and Romans prized its resin, called laser. By the first century it had died out, probably overharvested. The laser in Apicius, in 72 recipes, was most likely asafoetida imported from Persia, a stand-in for the lost plant.

Your spice rack was Rome’s medicine cabinet

A modern cook thinks of cinnamon, ginger and cardamom as things that go in food. In Imperial Rome, most imported aromatics were for something else, and the luxury Pliny complained about was mostly not food. Cinnamon, myrrh, spikenard and malabathrum, a fragrant Indian leaf, went into perfumed oils, ointments and medicines; their sources are mapped in Fig. 01. Frankincense and myrrh burned as offerings to the gods and at funerals; Pliny claims Nero burned more aromatics at his wife Poppaea’s funeral than Arabia produced in a year. Silphium, too, had a second life as medicine: ancient writers prescribed it for many ailments, including as a contraceptive.

Some of these uses survive. Frankincense is still burned in churches, and myrrh is still a perfume ingredient. Others have flipped: cinnamon, once a perfume, is now a baking spice. In Apicius, the imports barely register. Spikenard is in 8 recipes, ginger in 15, malabathrum in 3, cardamom in 1 and cinnamon in none.

Fish sauce and pepper in everything, even dessert

Garum, a salty sauce of fermented fish, is in 63% of recipes, making it the second most common ingredient after pepper; both turn up in almost every type of dish, including sweets. Historians such as Jean-Louis Flandrin trace the strict line between savory and sweet, which feels so natural in Italian and Western cooking today, to 17th-century France. Asafoetida, the likely laser, is a bold, garlicky resin found today mainly in Indian cooking.

Some ingredients, however, are totally recognizable today. Among the top six ingredients, olive oil is in 60% of recipes, wine in half, honey in 40% and vinegar in more than a third. The resulting dishes, such as spiced meats and wines, were probably a mix of recognizable and foreign to a modern palate. But when thinking about Italian cuisine today, so much is still missing: no tomatoes, which hadn’t yet crossed the Atlantic, no basil, butter or pasta, and cheese and garlic each appear in fewer than 10 of the 458 recipes.

How the pantry changed

To see what happened next, I counted the same ingredients, along with new ones, in two later cookbooks that were cornerstones of their time. Maestro Martino’s Libro de arte coquinaria, written around 1465 by a cook who had worked for a powerful cardinal in Rome, was the most influential Italian cookbook of its age. Pellegrino Artusi’s La scienza in cucina e l’arte di mangiar bene (1891) is the founding cookbook of Italy as a nation.

Apicius may not have been representative of all Roman cooking, but some ingredients, such as pepper and garum, are backed up by other sources. With only one book per era, take the data with a pinch of salt.

Fig. 03 · Rome, c. 1465, 1891Share of recipes
Apicius, Rome (compiled c. 400 CE) Maestro Martino, Italy (c. 1465) Artusi, Italy (1891)

Values above 80% run off the scale and are marked with an arrow. Hover a row for exact counts.

Show as a table

Pepper stayed. Almost everything else that made Roman food Roman quietly faded. By Martino’s time, garum, lovage, rue, cumin and laser are all gone. Honey, in 40% of Roman recipes, has dropped to almost nothing; sugar has taken its place, in 28% of Martino’s recipes and 34% of Artusi’s.

Martino’s kitchen also shows medieval Europe’s second spice boom. The imports Rome bought for perfume and medicine finally went into the pot: saffron is in 20% of his recipes, cinnamon in 18% and ginger in 17%, in savory dishes as well as sweet ones. They came with a new taste, sour verjuice from unripe grapes, almond milk and rosewater, that neither Rome nor modern Italy shares.

Then European ships changed the market. After the Portuguese reached India by sea in 1498, spices grew cheaper and more plentiful, and without scarcity they lost much of their luxury appeal. The same voyages brought new foods from the Americas. By 1891, Artusi’s cinnamon is down to 5% of recipes, ginger and saffron to under 1%, and verjuice and rosewater to nothing. Butter has overtaken olive oil, in 60% of his recipes against 31%, and tomatoes are already in 15%. Olive oil’s return to the center of Italian cooking came later.

Fewer spices per dish

Roman cooks also used more seasonings at once. The average Roman recipe calls for 2.8 different spices and herbs, and one in twenty uses seven or more. By Martino’s time the average is 1.2, and by Artusi’s, 1.0, with more than a third of his recipes using none at all.

Fig. 04 · Spices and herbs per recipeShare of recipes
Apicius (458) Martino c. 1465 (262) Artusi 1891 (790)

Dishes & their ingredients are products of their time

So is Italian food Roman? In its pantry, only a little. Pepper, olive oil and wine made the whole journey from Apicius to Artusi. Almost everything else that made Roman food Roman, from garum and lovage to honey and laser, quietly faded. The spices Rome bought for perfume had their moment in the kitchen centuries later, then faded too, once trade made them cheap.

Even the dishes we now think of as traditionally Italian are recent. Consider carbonara, built from spaghetti, eggs, cheese, cured pork and pepper. It’s the dish many people picture when they think of Rome, but it first appears in print in the 1950s. Neapolitan pizza, with its tomato, basil and cheese, was literally impossible in ancient Rome: the tomato didn’t reach Italy until the 1540s.

A cuisine, in other words, is less an inheritance than a snapshot of what its cooks could buy and what was in fashion. Some ingredients and techniques do get passed down, but the dishes that come to define a culture are usually far newer than they feel.

Obviously, Apicius on its own may not represent Roman cooking, but it’s one of the best glimpses we’ve got, and what we see matches what we know from other sources: (1) garum was a common Roman ingredient; (2) pepper was used across classes, in grades of differing value; and (3) the imported spices missing from the book were used as medicine, as offerings to the gods and as perfume. To better understand how food evolves under the constraints and trends of its time, or gets passed down through the generations, we’ll explore the medieval era next.

About the data

I counted ingredients in three books with a dictionary of period and modern names for each ingredient, so "laser" counts as silphium, Vehling’s "broth" as garum, and "formaggio grattugiato" as Parmesan. An ingredient counts once per recipe however often it’s named. Each book is one elite or middle-class collection, so these numbers show how a book’s readers were told to cook, not what everyone ate.

Full method notes

Apicius. Joseph Dommers Vehling’s 1936 English translation, Books I–X, 458 numbered recipes. His commentary, footnotes and bracketed insertions are excluded. The Excerpts of Vinidarius, a later appendix, are left out here, so counts differ slightly from my earlier 498-recipe count. Laser is counted with silphium; the text calls it Parthian, so it was most likely asafoetida.

Maestro Martino. Lisa’s amateur English translation (shainer.github.io, CC BY 4.0), 262 recipes; the translator’s own notes, set in italics, are excluded. Martino often calls for unnamed "good spices" or "sweet spices" (in 70 recipes), so named-spice counts are a floor. "Fatty broth" is meat broth and is not counted as garum. Almonds include almond milk; verjuice includes the Italian "agresto"; reduced must includes "sapa". "Grated cheese" counts as Parmesan, as "formaggio grattugiato" does in Artusi, and "pig fat" counts as lard.

Artusi. The Italian original, 790 numbered recipes.

Ingredient explorer (Fig. 02). Uses a finer 170-ingredient dictionary than the cross-book charts, restricted to the same 458 recipes. "Wine" there means plain wine only, with raisin wine and reduced must counted separately, so a few totals differ slightly from Fig. 03.

Spices and herbs per recipe (Fig. 04). Counts distinct spices and herbs from one shared list of 37, including sage, rosemary, dill, juniper and chilli so the modern books aren’t undercounted. Onion, garlic, citrus and celery stalks are not included. Modern recipes that say "salt and pepper" count pepper.